When thinking about the most important moment(s) of your life, do you still feel the full range of emotion associated with that memory? What if you keep recalling the same memory many times, does the intensity of emotion fade?
Just anecdotally from my own life, they become more like thinking back to a dream you had last night. There is a knowledge of, or a familiarity with the emotions, but a lack of definite certainty about the content. You know it’s yours, you know what it meant, you know what you experienced, but without reality to guide you and only through memory. When you do experience the guidance of reality, through songs, words, sights, smells, then the clarity/intensity can also come back. And that doesn’t fade or I wouldn’t use that word, you can get so familiar to it that it isn’t carrying the weight it once did. Loss feels like loss, shame like shame, love like love… It’s not that it fades into nothing, or that the quality of it diminishes. It’s more that you bought a summer coat but it’s winter now, it’s not needed anymore. Still beautiful, still wearable, still looking good on you, just that it isn’t the right thing to wear right now.
Did it ever happen to you that you had a memory about something happening long time ago and than, when you thought about it you realized it was just a dream? Happened to me couple of times.
I think I do recognise the feeling. There isn’t really a big difference remembering something that happened a long time ago or from a dream. There is when you get a physical reminder (smells in particular seem to be a strong trigger). Both dreams and memories work in the same way from the perspective of your own subjective experience. Especially dreams have a very hard time making physical memories, since your body is in rest. But when you’re awake and especially when you’re aroused in some way, your body connects the memories to the physical sensations. In this sense your body is a memory bank and it stores your life. Your body grows, cleans, encapsulates, expulses, incorporates, so do the connections change or get lost in pure subjective memory.
It’s this that can explain why old memories and dreams can feel so much alike.
<3
You can do this on purpose to, for example, remove the traumatic emotions associated with a memory, but this doesn’t happen easily nor unintentionally
It’s part of why hypnosis works on some.
This brought to my mind Coherence Therapy and its emphasis on memory reconsolidation. Also this therapy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFdSd5ow0yw
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
https://www.piped.video/watch?v=WFdSd5ow0yw
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.
This is a fun but old podcast by Radiolab that talks about the subject. Kinda crazy how our brains basically destroy and recreate memories whenever we recall them.
I remember remembering my 4th birthday cake. I remember remembering it. But the actual memory is gone. As is anything from before I was maybe 7.
I remember remembering my 4th birthday cake. I remember remembering it. But the actual memory is gone. As is anything from before I was maybe 7.
“Core memory” doesn’t mean emotional. It means formative. It’s something that makes you who you are, and emotion doesn’t have to be tied to that.
So exhausting the emotion doesn’t mean exhausting the core memory.
Strong emotion is most often a lack of processing. Once your brain processes something sufficiently, the emotion fades. That doesn’t mean it doesn’t affect who you are.
Only if they are good. The bad ones you have to keep forever and relive it every time a minor inconvenience happens
Talk to a therapist. Not just you, everyone.
We all have trauma, talking about it can help you come to peace with it. Then it won’t be this cringe thing (or whatever negative emotion it invokes) in your thought pattern.
Well… Sometimes, even the bad ones, the worst ones, can be exhausted too.
I think the mechanism in your brain exists
Think of a song that you find pretty sad, overtime the more you play it, it loses it’s emotional influence on you. Therefore I think it is indeed possible for the emotions in a memory to weaken overtime and eventually, whether for better or for worse, disappear entirely
Absolutely, I met Ronald Reagan in 1990 as a kid and thought it was great. Knowing all the shit he did and that his mind wasn’t there erased any emotion I had of that.
I think this question would fit better on askscience.
The short answer is that the emotions themselves don’t “fade”, but every time you recall a memory, you are also recalling all previous recalls, and the emotions related to the event you remember are not the same as the emotions on each subsequent recall.
We use computers as an analogy for the 🧠, and there are some reasons for that, but they are not the same, and this analogy have limits.
The brain evolved to keep us alive, and reproduce. Keep a perfect record of previous events would be costly and unnecessary for that. “Learn the lesson” and keep a registry that resembles the past is enough.
(But I’m not a neuroscientist, so I may be wrong, missing something or not updated)
Mmm. Good question. If it’s traumatic, I’d be concerned that it would only increase the intensity to focus on it like that.
